Vermont This Week
February 28, 2025
2/28/2025 | 26m 41sVideo has Closed Captions
Governor releases education reform bill | Sen. Sanders ‘Fighting Oligarchy’ tour
Governor releases education reform bill | Senator Sanders ‘Fighting Oligarchy’ tour | Some Canadians are skipping Vermont for the next four years | Panel: Mikaela Lefrak - Moderator, Vermont Public; Kevin McCallum - Seven Days; Brittany Patterson - Vermont Public; Ethan Weinstein - VTDigger.
Vermont This Week is a local public television program presented by Vermont Public
Sponsored in part by Lintilhac Foundation and Milne Travel.
Vermont This Week
February 28, 2025
2/28/2025 | 26m 41sVideo has Closed Captions
Governor releases education reform bill | Senator Sanders ‘Fighting Oligarchy’ tour | Some Canadians are skipping Vermont for the next four years | Panel: Mikaela Lefrak - Moderator, Vermont Public; Kevin McCallum - Seven Days; Brittany Patterson - Vermont Public; Ethan Weinstein - VTDigger.
How to Watch Vermont This Week
Vermont This Week is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.

Support the crew
Help Mitch keep the conversations going as a member of Vermont Public. Join us today and support independent journalism.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship-!With key legislative deadlines -fast approaching, Governor -Scott's administration -unveils their education -reform proposal.
-Vermont's government -structure is complex, with 52 -supervisory unions, under -!which there are 119 districts.
-We can't just -make small tweaks.
-We must redesign our system.
-Plus, a look inside Senator -Bernie Sanders -fighting oligarchy tour, -and why some Canadians -are skipping Vermont -for the next four years.
-All of that and more ahead -on Vermont This Week.
-!From the Vermont Public studio -in Winooski -this is Vermont This Week.
-Made possible in part -by the Lintilhac Foundation -and Milne Travel.
-Thanks for joining us -on Vermont This Week.
-I'm Mikaela -LeFrak in for Mitch Wertlieb.
-It is Friday, February 28th.
-Joining us on the panel -this week is Kevin McCallum -from Seven Days.
-Ethan Weinstein from Vtdigger -and Brittany Patterson -from Vermont Public.
-Thank you all for being here.
-!Town Meeting Day is next week.
-And many of you -probably remember -!last year as Town Meeting Day, -when nearly a third of budget -school budgets failed.
-People all around -the state were concerned -about their rising property -taxes.
-Now, legislators -and the governor -made some short term changes -to the education -funding system, but -they've also vowed to come up -with a longer term fix.
-This week, Governor Phil -!Scott introduced his education -transformation -bill to the legislature.
-Ethan, -!you were tasked with reviewing -all 176 pages of it.
-What stood out to you?
-Well, Mikayla, -this has been -the most anticipated piece -of legislation this year.
-And although the governor and -his team have been releasing -bits and pieces of it -throughout the session, -we got our first -look this week.
-You know, -in, in broad strokes, -the governor wants -to consolidate Vermont school -districts from, -more than 100 down to five.
-And he wants to transition -the state to what's -called a foundation formula.
-!This would be a new way to pay -for education.
-A lot of what we saw in 176 -pages, were things -that we could have predicted, -but, a few of the surprises -or key details, -that I highlighted -were, class size minimums.
-He's looking at, -bringing the size of fourth -to 12th grade classes -to, 25 students at a minimum.
-That's a big change for a lot -of Vermont's small schools.
-He's also proposing, -very strict restrictions -on private schools eligible -to receive public dollars.
-This is a contentious issue -for Democrats and Republicans -alike.
-And, I think those were, -a couple of the the details -that really got people's -attention.
Yeah.
-Can you say a little bit more -about the restrictions -on private schools -that are eligible -for public dollars?
-Because, as you said, -this has been something -that, you know, -when we talk about it -on Vermont Edition, people -feel a lot of feelings -about this one.
-Yeah, it's it's, -it's a bit wonky.
-So, you know, -something like 95 -or 90% of Vermont students -attend public school.
-But there's this, -smaller percentage -who can use public dollars -to attend private school -if their school -district doesn't operate -a public school.
-What Governor -Scott is proposing -is that only schools that -!currently only private schools -that currently enroll -!more than 51% tuition students -would be eligible to continue -receiving public dollars.
-And in practice, -!this means that only something -like 6 or 7 schools, -would be able -to receive public funds.
-And right now, you know, -it's it's dozens and dozens.
-So Governor -Scott has introduced -this bill to the legislature, -which is still Democrat -controlled.
-I want to talk about -some of the responses -that we've been hearing -from Democratic leadership.
-Because there has been -some pushback -specifically around the, -foundation -formula, as it's called.
-Here's Representative Charles -Kimball, -who's a Democrat -from Woodstock.
-We will look at adopting -a foundation formula, but -!we don't think the current way -it's constructed is right.
-And so we're not going -to rush into -just adopting a foundation -formula -for the sake of doing it.
-We want to make sure -the numbers are right.
-We don't think -we can get all that done -in this legislative session.
-It seems -like there's a bit of a time -crunch Democrats are saying.
-Yeah I mean I think as that -clip suggests, there's, -there's consensus that -the state -is probably moving -in this direction.
-The question is, -you know, the ROE, -the agency of education, -they've brought forward -their idea -for a foundation formula.
-And I think that, -Democratic leadership, -they want to have -the opportunity -to work with their own -consultants, -their own experts, develop -a plan in tandem.
-And, you know, maybe find -a, a middle ground -rather than relying -entirely on these -very complicated equations -and modeling performed -by the administration.
-And, Ethan, one last thing.
-As we mentioned, town -meeting day is next week.
-Is, education going to be -your focus?
-Is your you're -talking to voters next week?
-It'll be my focus.
-I know I'm hearing -!a lot of different predictions -in terms of, -whether we'll see something -like last year.
-I think, -you know, -I'm not in the prediction -business, but -but people are suggesting, -they expect fewer school -budgets will fail than last -year.
-Well, well, education -funding has dominated -the conversation -in Montpelier over -these last couple of months, -but it is far from -the only issue that lawmakers -have been discussing there.
-Brittany, -you've been following -some proposed changes -to hunting regulations -in the state.
-What?
What's going on?
-Yeah.
-So these regulations -are coming from, -the Fish and Wildlife -Department in Vermont.
-They were made by -the 14 member wildlife board, -but the agency's biologists, -support them.
-And really, there's a couple -different regulations -on the table.
-Turkey, some moose changes, -a little bit of changes to -how meat is transported -from out of state into state.
-I think the most, -!substantial changes are around -the deer hunting regulations.
-So tell us a little bit more.
-They tried to.
-It sounds like they're trying -to cull more deer.
-Yes.
With the same amount -of hunters in Vermont.
-How do you do that?
-That's exactly right.
-So for the first time in -perhaps decades, Vermont -is proposing to open up -the regular fall season.
-And that's when most we have -the most hunters hunting.
-Currently, -!hunters are only hunting bucks -during that season.
-But the agency -wants to open it up -so that they can hunt doughs -with, rifles and shotguns.
-And the idea really is that -when when you're talking to -!biologists, there are too many -female deers.
-Sometimes called antler -antlerless deers in certain -parts of the state, -and not enough hunters -to to be able -to take care of them -to reduce those populations.
-And so, -the Fish and Wildlife -Department -thinks that by opening up -regular season in this way, -some 20 to 25,000 -additional hunters -who only hunt during -the regular season -!will now have the opportunity, -if they want to, to -shoot a doe, and that could -!have potentially a big impact.
-Okay.
-So potentially my -garden will not be consumed -as terribly as it was.
-Are there other -negative impacts -of having too many deer -in the state -other than, you know, eating -all of my rainbow chard?
-Yeah, absolutely.
-So it's not just your garden -that is, you know, -often times decimated -by our dear friends, -where there is -an overabundance of deer, -we see often certain species -in the forest, -in that forest understory, -especially, -that are over eaten.
-And then that decreases the -overall health of the forest.
-And then that makes it hard -for all of the species -that are in that environment -to be able to thrive.
-And so, -you know, biologists say -the state needs more levers -to be able to control -this deer population.
-And hunting is a big -one of those.
-These rules would also, -if passed, -they would open up our tree -season -during the regular season.
-And in some cases allow some -!hunters to take a second buck.
-and in other news -from Montpelier, -Governor Phil -Scott wants the legislature -to exempt military pensions -from state income taxes.
-Ethan and Kevin, -I know you guys have both, -reported on this a bit.
-Kevin, let's -let's get you in here first.
-What?
-Why is this an issue -that the governor is pushing?
-Well, he's long felt that, -if Vermont did away, -with taxation of military -pensions, -that it would cause -military veterans -to decide to move -here, basically, -that as military veterans -look toward -the end of their career, -where are they going to go -next?
-That they look -at the tax structure and say, -here's here's our options.
-And, Vermont is -one of only three states, -I think, in the nation -that taxes military pensions.
-And so he's long thought -that if you got rid of that, -we would get off on a flood, -but certainly a decent number -of, of, military veterans -moving to the state.
-And he has a very high regard -for military -veterans -in terms of their skills -and their leadership -abilities, -and their work ethic.
-And so we've heard for years -that he wanted -to do away with this.
-!But Democrats have always kind -of viewed it as a tax break.
-Right.
-Where are we going -to give tax breaks -to one -individual group of people.
-But it seems as though, -this idea is gaining -a little more traction -this year, in part because, -he's pushing the labor angle.
-It's like, these are not -!retirees who are done working.
-These are often people -who've got a 20 year -career in the military, -are now in their 40s -and 50s and in the prime -of their working lives.
-And the idea is if, -yeah, if you can get -a military veteran -to move here at the age of 45 -with two kids, buy a house -and join the workforce, -that would be -a perfect opportunity -to boost the Vermont's -workforce.
-So it's a workforce -issue, too, isn't -just what you're here.
-Yeah.
-I mean, as Kevin mentions, -a lot of these folks -retire at an age -when they still really -want to work.
-The governor, as part of his -budget this year, presented, -I think, 13.5 million -in, tax breaks.
-And a bunch of them have been -popular ideas for Democrats, -expanding the child -tax credit, -expanding the earned income -tax credit.
-These are things that -Democratic leadership have, -seemingly bought into.
-And maybe this is the year -we finally see some movement -on this -military pension exemption.
-Oh, well, Brittany, -you recently attended -the Northeast Kingdom -!lobbying day at the Statehouse -in Montpelier.
-I'm curious, -is there -any particular concern -from folks who live in -that part of our region?
-The that they were bringing -to lawmakers -or any of the issues -that we've discussed today -or those, on people's minds?
-Yeah.
-You know, -there was a really good -showing of folks -from all across the Kingdom -for any K day.
-And I think, by and large, -the thing that emerged -as the most, important -!and the one they really wanted -to stress to -lawmakers is concerning -is the idea of losing access -to rural health care.
-So folks are probably -familiar with this file, -the Oliver Wyman report -that came out, -that was commissioned -by the state -and calls -for really big changes -to the way -Vermont's health care system -works in order to make it -sustainable.
-And a lot of those changes -are rural hospitals, -potential closures, -potential cuts.
-And, -both the CEO of the hospital -in Saint Johnsbury -and the CEO of North Country -Hospital in Newport -were at and K day -and had been lobbying -lawmakers -all that week and beyond, -really trying -to push the message home -that if we lose -these hospitals -or if we hollowed them out -to the point where, -you know, it's basically -not something -that where you can get -emergency care, for example, -they're going to lose -the like that's going to be -!the end for these communities.
-Like they're already seeing, -challenges -hiring for the hospital.
-But also in convincing people -to come to the region.
-Because if you can't get good -health care, -you need to drive an hour.
-And it's emergency.
Like, -that's a challenging thing to -to have to to balance.
-Yeah, yeah.
-And I know that you've -also been keeping a close eye -on, the the incoming tariffs -from the Trump -administration on Canada.
-And I can imagine -those would have a, -bit of a unique impact -on the Northeast Kingdom, -maybe on tourism, as well, -being so close to the border.
-Yeah, absolutely.
-I spent the last week -actually reporting out the, -some Canadians are canceling -visits this summer, -especially up -in the Northeast Kingdom.
-I talked to, -someone who owns, -!lodging off of Kingdom Trails.
-Talk to the CEO of, Jay Peak.
-And, you know, up -in the Kingdom and in parts -even of northern Vermont, -we're talking about 30% -or more of the business -being generated -by the Canadian market.
-And so, -I think it could be -a big chunk of, of change -for especially folks -in communities -that are on the border, -to see -some of these Canadians, -you know, -make the hard decision -to to take a step back -and to not frequent Vermont -right now, -because of the rhetoric -!that's coming out of the Trump -administration.
-Ministration, -which includes these tariffs, -which -as of right now are slated to -go into effect next Tuesday.
-Kevin, -you have spent a lot of time -over the last couple of days -reporting -on, some of the unique -overlaps between the Trump -!administration's policies and, -our local leaders -response to those.
-But you weren't in Vermont.
-You went to the Midwest, -I sure did.
-!What were you doing out there?
-!I was following Bernie Sanders -around the Midwest -as he went on his Fighting -Oligarchy tour.
-He has, -gotten back in the saddle, -basically, and decided -that the only effective way -for the left to push back on -some of the policies -out of the white House -is to put pressure -on Republican lawmakers, -to do the right thing -and to stand up to Trump.
-And so what he -and his people decided to do -was to head to the Midwest, -to, Omaha -and also to Iowa City, -to hold really big rallies -and to try to urge people -to call their congresspeople -and say, do not vote -for the budget reconciliation -bill, which was up for a key -vote the other day.
-And so I like we should get -this out of the way first.
-Did it work?
It didn't work.
-It didn't work.
-No.
Only one Republican, -I think, stood up -and, opposed that bill -and he only needed two.
-So it was a very close -and very dramatic vote.
-And frankly, -my story was, ready to run.
-And we had to rewrite -the thing -!because the vote was happening -at like 8:00 -at night on Tuesday.
-And so it was very close.
-It was, you know, people -it was surprising to see -Bernie Sanders -still able to generate -huge enthusiasm -!and huge crowds in the Midwest -when he wasn't -running for anything.
Right.
-He's going there on an issue.
-And so, he didn't -and he was surprised -he his team originally -planned, to hold a rally in a -small to moderate size Union -Hall in the suburbs of Omaha.
-And then they had this RSVP, -you know, -thing on their website about -who wants to come to this.
-And it just went -through the roof.
-And so they had to cancel -their venue, move -to downtown Omaha -into a marriott -to be able to accommodate -what turned out to be 3400 -people who showed up, -many of them -just extremely excited -and gratified to see Vermont -senior senator urging them -on, urging them to fight, -urging them to push back.
-Because, you know, -there's a lot of the people -I spoke with, many of them -have felt quite, hopeless -in the last couple of months -since Trump's reelection.
-And they don't know -what to do.
-It's like, -what am I supposed to do?
-I'm seeing this chaos -out of out of DC.
-I don't agree with any of -the things that he's doing.
-What am I as a voter, as -!an individual, supposed to do?
-Well, Bernie was giving them -a path, right?
-Bernie was saying, here's -what you do.
-You make some calls, -you send some emails, -you push back, you fight.
-And that message -really resonated -with a lot of people.
-So it was a fun trip.
-It was exhausting.
-It was short, but it was, -it was an impressive -showing for Vermont, -you know, Senator, -and you and the senator -caught the same play back -here.
-We did.
-We did end up -being on the same flight out -of, out of Chicago, -back to Burlington.
-And that was interesting -to see, too, -because he, you know, -!if there was ever any question -about his sort of rock star -status, you know, -the guy -walks through an airport and people are like, -can I get a selfie -with you, Senator?
-You know, -I appreciate you, Senator.
-You know, -there's all this sort of -you know, he's -!he's a national public figure.
-And so it's, it follows him -everywhere he goes.
-Well, -he is not the only member -of Vermont's -congressional delegation -who has been pushing back -against some of the Trump -administration's policies.
-The three person delegation -held a virtual town -hall this past week, -and it reported its massive -attendance numbers.
-34,000 -people tuned in virtually.
-Let's take a look at what -that was like.
-We have Vermont farmers who, -with the commitment -of the federal government, -signed a contract -where if they borrowed money -to do -environmentally sensitive -things that are going -to help their farm -and help our climate, -they would get paid back -by the federal government.
-They got emails saying -no, that's on hold, -you're on your own.
-And we hear from farmers -who don't know -how they're going to pay -the bills.
-The concern that I'm hearing -from Vermonters -who are calling and writing -and who -I'm seeing on the street, -that we have a constitutional -crisis in the making.
-You're right.
You're right.
-I know there are quite -a few people in Vermont -!who who supported Donald Trump -in the last election, -and I know I speak -for my colleagues here.
-It does not matter to us -who you voted for.
-What matters to us -is how Vermonters are going -to survive this moment.
-I need you to know -that we represent -so many of our colleagues -who see this as we do -a critical moment -when the democracy -is on the line -and they are going to have -to get through us -to tear this down.
-They're going to have to get -through us to tear this down.
-Kevin, thoughts -on that message?
-Yeah, that's it's it's -tough talk -and it's lofty -rhetoric and it's, impressive -that the three of them, -I think, you know, -got together and presented -!a united front that, you know, -and it was a message I think -Vermonters needed to hear, -but ultimately, right, -the vote, as I already said, -the vote, the other day, -didn't, didn't pan out.
-And so I think there's -this open question about, -you know, -what Becca saying there is -they're going to have -to come through us -to tear down the government -and that it looks -as though they have the votes -to be able to do that.
-And so, I'm not entirely sure -how much resistance.
-Right.
-!The Democrats and independents -from Vermont -or elsewhere in the Congress -are really going to be able -to, to to present -to some of the things -that the Republicans -are up to.
-!Well, we've talked about some, -state level resistance, -!some on the ground resistance, -including from Canadians -who are choosing -not to spend their dollars -in the United States -over the next four years.
-One person who isn't skipping -Vermont, though, is Vice -President JD Vance.
-He and his family -!are coming to Sugarbush to ski -this weekend.
-Local officials -and businesses are preparing -for their family to arrive, -as well as dozens of secret -!Service agents and protesters.
-Now, Governor -Phil Scott issued a statement -today, welcomed the vice -president and his family -!and noted the good ski weather -that we've had this winter.
-He also reminded Vermonters -to be respectful, -even if they disagree -with the vice president -and the Trump -administration's policies.
-Since the vice president -is traveling -with his young children.
-All right.
-There are so many different -ways that the Trump -administration's policies -have, been affected.
-!Vermonters on the state level.
-One thing that was -interesting that I'm hoping -you could help us understand -this change that could come, -lawmakers are thinking -about taking away -authority or taking authority -over partnerships -with federal immigration -authorities.
-Why are they -thinking about doing that?
-Yeah, it's, it's -a little bit wonky, -!but as the law is written now, -we're, President Trump -to declare a state -of emergency at Vermont's -northern border with Canada.
-It would basically open up -the opportunity -for law enforcement, -you know, town -police departments -or sheriff's departments -to enter into agreements -with Ice or Border Patrol.
-We've heard calls from -President Trump, obviously, -for mass deportations -and mass incarceration -and rounding people up -the way the law is written.
-Now, only Governor Scott -would have authority to enter -into these partnerships.
-But, we've seen that -President Trump is willing -to declare states -of emergencies -for things that, many might -not consider emergencies.
-And so Democratic -lawmakers are concerned that, -this could this could be -a problem for us.
-Yeah, yeah.
-And, you know, I thought -it was interesting that, -that the -Democrats initially -pushed to have a say in -whether the governor struck -these deals and allowed, -agreements -to go forward with Ice -because for that exact -reason.
Right.
-They don't want the governor -to be the sole authority -in the state of Vermont -for whether Ice is able -to come and conduct sweeps, -in the state with the -with the assistance -of state law enforcement.
-So they're like, hey, -why don't you come -to us and ask us -if we're okay with that?
-And we can have a combined -jurisdiction over that.
-We can have a shared power -over whether ice, -collaboration -occurs in the state.
-And very quickly, -the governor's people -shut that down.
-They said, look, I'm -the executive.
-!I'm the governor of the state.
-I have the power to do this.
-And it makes no sense -to allow the legislature to -come in -and also have a say in that.
-And so I just think he felt -it was an overreach.
-And so it went away -pretty quickly.
-I don't think that piece -is in the bill anymore.
-There is some desire -to sort of -put some guardrails around -what immigration -officials can do in the state -that are not quite -worked out yet, -but that big picture idea -of lawmakers having a say, -in Ice raids and Ice -in immigration -work in the state is is dead.
-And, Brittney, you again -were reported on the, -NK lobby day.
-You're also planning to -go up to the J area on town -meeting Day, -as this issue of immigration -and border security -come up -in any of your conversations -with with folks -who live in that region?
-Yeah, that's a good question.
-I think we have been hearing -trickles of -people starting to ask, like, -are we headed toward -like a war with Canada?
-What will that mean for these -communities on the border?
-You know, -I think it's -probably far too early -to to go that direction.
-But I think there is -a lot of concern, -especially in communities -where, you know, -the back and forth over -the border is -is something that happens -all the time.
-And concerns over like, -yeah, what, -what that relationship -is going to look like -moving forward.
-You, -you also reported Brittany -on a University -of New Hampshire poll.
-They pulled Vermonters -on their approval ratings -for President Donald Trump.
-What did that study find?
-!I think you won't be surprised -to hear it -didn't find anything -super surprising, -that things really break -down on the Partizan level.
-So, you know, -one third of Vermonters -approve of Donald Trump's -performance so far, -whereas two thirds do not.
-And it was really like -Republicans -giving the support to Trump -and Democrats really not.
-So like if we break -it down for that one third, -and it was 86% -of Republicans thought Trump -was doing a good job -when only 1% of Democrats -did an 18% of independents.
-So it's very much Partizan.
-The University of New -Hampshire Survey Center.
-And they do this quite, -quite often.
-They also looked at executive -orders and, no surprise.
-Still a breakdown.
-Partizan lead -Democrats really disagreeing -with a lot of Trump's -executive orders -early on in his tenure.
-Republicans supporting them.
-Well, there's going to be -lots of change ahead -when it comes to the Trump -administration's -policies and their effect -on this region.
-I'm so glad that -all three of you -are covering it in your own -ways.
-Let's end on some Michaela -related news.
-The greatest -ski racer of all time.
-!At least I'm going to say that -because she's a fellow.
-Mikaela.
-Mikaela Shiffrin has become -the first person ever to win -a 100 World Cup -alpine ski races -in the 58 year -history of the competition.
-She went to Burke -Mountain Academy, -so we like to claim her -as our own.
-And after coming overcoming -!a puncture wound in Killington -back in November, -she went on to secure -this historic win in Italy -this past weekend.
-So congratulations -to Mikaela Shiffrin -and a reminder yet again -that Town Meeting Day -is this coming Tuesday, -March 4th.
-We hope you all have -productive meetings and votes -and maybe a free slice of pie -as well.
-Next week -we are going to recap town -Meeting day -!results will also provide some -through lines and analysis -for you all as well.
-Until then I'm Mikaela LeFrak -and thank you so much -for tuning in.
-That's where we're going -!to have to leave it for today.
-Our panel is Kevin McCallum -from seven days, Ethan -Weinstein from Vtdigger -and Brittany Patterson -from Vermont Public.
-Thank you all -for watching and listening.
-And.
Vermont This Week is a local public television program presented by Vermont Public
Sponsored in part by Lintilhac Foundation and Milne Travel.